Skip to content

πŸ›πŸ§‘β€πŸ’» - Released acceptance recovery exhausts on R11 in three unchanged Domus evaluationsΒ #937

Closed

Description

@efraespada

Is there an existing issue for this?

  • I have searched the existing issues.

Related to #932, #933, #925 and #829. The #932 recovery is present and exercised. This report records the remaining live-provider qualification boundary after three complete evaluations with the released recovery.

Which actions are affected?

Commits

Which platforms are affected?

Linux

Description

Released 3.10.11 repeatedly invokes its bounded acceptance replacement for Domus #29, then rejects that replacement at the first requirement R11 / original source L11. All three complete attempts preserve the original source and successfully collect all comparison evidence. Zero acceptance batches reach completion or publication.

The complete consumer remains blocked while independent CI and Bugbot are green. Expected operational qualification is a supported route to a complete, validated assessment of this admitted inventory with the configured provider. Preserve every original requirement/citation, hard fact allocation, complete-result fence and fixed budgets. The existing negative controls correctly preserve state on oversized output. The current result also needs an honest operational status and a recovery strategy that does not depend on indefinite whole-comparison repeats.

Reproducing the issue

Unchanged consumer inputs for every run are Domus issue #23 / PR #29, head fbb4cfd1d8160e63a6b4d62e4ac118fb2f946a0c, base 5b7bdcdee3a9e98d6669bfd34ce750ae30a8c775. All jobs resolve released v3 to 0bb87c4.

Complete attempt Accepted comparison Acceptance result Check
7 Ten classification batches, all 17 comparison parts First batch of four; complete replacement still returns 61 Unicode points against 54 128559158553
8 Ten classification batches, all 17 comparison parts First batch of five; complete replacement still returns 50 against 40 128562593263
9 Ten classification batches, all 17 comparison parts First batch of six; complete replacement still returns 43 against 35 128566218481

Each diagnostic binds the replacement failure to phase assessment, R11, L11, $.requirements[0].remaining. The classification and allocation variations are observed results for the same unchanged human source. Exact classified counts and private response text are unavailable in the retained native diagnostics. The source case inventory remains unchanged.

copilot Version

v3.10.11, Action commit 0bb87c4. This is actual hosted execution of the released artifact.

Relevant Log Output

Attempt 7 correlation de5d1928-6ad2-4dc0-bea5-87aa2b66ea6d
23:13:14 Requesting one complete replacement for the same pinned batch.
23:13:58 Replacement still exceeds the unchanged limit: R11 / L11 / remaining, 61 / 54 points.

Attempt 8 correlation ee6f4e14-ff6f-426f-a67c-aaa8dbe0e637
23:28:11 Requesting one complete replacement for the same pinned batch.
23:28:52 Replacement still exceeds the unchanged limit: R11 / L11 / remaining, 50 / 40 points.

Attempt 9 correlation 59d4d45e-87be-4734-8010-61a93452869f
23:44:08 Requesting one complete replacement for the same pinned batch.
23:44:52 Replacement still exceeds the unchanged limit: R11 / L11 / remaining, 43 / 35 points.

Times are UTC on 2026-11-07. All checks report agent.failed, mark the condition retryable and preserve old progress. The private rejected prose has not been retained or reconstructed. Original fixed bounds remain unchanged.

Additional context and comments

PR #933 introduces the requested bounded replacement and safe measured diagnostics. The actual consumer confirms both behaviors. Its archived deterministic qualification retains 108 requirements and citations, but these three live-provider attempts all stop at R11 before complete consumer acceptance. This report asks for that operational gap to remain actionable while preserving the proven guard behavior.

Please qualify any supported generation/recovery improvement against the original consumer scope and the exact same-head publication fence. Distinguish a protocol/fixture pass from live-provider acceptance. Keep the allocation, citations, semantics, one-publication rule and attempt budgets explicit. Do not retain rejected prose or solve this by weakening source scope, changing case counts, truncating facts or granting an acceptance exception.

Domus CI and Bugbot are green for fbb4cfd. All 27 review threads are resolved. The user requires all three gates green before merge. PR #29 therefore remains open. The earlier two consumer observations are retained in #932 and its second-attempt comment. No consumer source, configuration or installed resource was modified during these evaluations.

Activity

  1. added
    bugSomething isn't working
    bugfixSomething isn't working
    priority: highCritical issue, needs immediate attention.
    on Nov 7, 2026
  2. added theissue type on Nov 7, 2026
  3. moved this to Todo in vypdevon Nov 7, 2026
  4. vypbot commented on Nov 7, 2026

    @vypbot
    Contributor

    Hi! I’m @vypbot, the Copilot assistant for this repository.

    I can answer questions, explain the codebase, propose implementation and test plans, review issues and pull requests for potential bugs or security problems, and help authorized maintainers apply changes.

    Try /copilot help to see the available commands, or mention @vypbot with your question.

  5. moved this from Todo to In Progress in vypdevon Nov 8, 2026
  6. added
    branchedIndicates that a branch has been created for this issue.
    on Nov 8, 2026
  7. changed the title [-]πŸ› - Released acceptance recovery exhausts on R11 in three unchanged Domus evaluations[/-] [+]πŸ›πŸ§‘β€πŸ’» - Released acceptance recovery exhausts on R11 in three unchanged Domus evaluations[/+] on Nov 8, 2026
  8. added
    state:workingWork can proceed on the verified branch or without a branch.
    on Nov 8, 2026
  9. 35 remaining items

  10. efraespada commented on Nov 8, 2026

    @efraespada
    MemberAuthor

    The broader readiness audit found one more reproducible boundary before merge. SDK predecessor e04474ac5fd89e33d00eb69c7da26d05d7103ac5 passed all three hosted platforms, CI, native review/verification and official patch coverage (280/280 hits). Merge was kept on hold because the reverse transition also exposed a premature test predicate: the future-schema notice can appear while the explicit read button is still disabled. A click at that real client boundary submits zero subsequent reads.

    Follow-up 0efaba9412a4b07f49706154cb28942db00d52c9 applies one completed-current-read/available-toolbar helper to all six explicit recovery reads in the existing catalog battery. Every original assertion, request count, revision fence, timeout/retry setting and coverage floor is preserved. All 14 existing cases plus the temporary deterministic boundary diagnostic pass; normal hooks pass build, 920 root suites / 18,293 tests (35 existing skips), and lint. The temporary diagnostic is retained outside test discovery; no test declarations were added.

    Relative to the actually qualified SDK aeb01425e490744fb0d66ac1184bab1133b0c6ce, the only changed tracked file is this test. Production source, workflows, dependencies and all four runtime bundles remain byte-identical. The actual Domus qualification is retained with that explicit runtime-equivalence proof. Fresh platform, CI, native review/verification and official Codecov gates now apply to 0efaba9412a4b07f49706154cb28942db00d52c9; no SDK or Domus merge has occurred.

  11. vypbot commented on Nov 8, 2026

    @vypbot
    Contributor

    Issue closed: synchronization recommendation retired

    No branch synchronization is required for this closed issue.

    The previous recommendation is historical. Issue closure does not certify that the branches are synchronized.

  12. moved this from In Progress to Done in vypdevon Nov 8, 2026
  13. added
    100%Progress: 100%
    and removed
    in-progressStart work on an admitted issue.
    state:workingWork can proceed on the verified branch or without a branch.
    on Nov 8, 2026
  14. efraespada commented on Nov 8, 2026

    @efraespada
    MemberAuthor

    Merged #938 into develop at 5bee5ef58daebdfa8288bd757763850bc5494a46. GitHub also marked #939 merged through the same commit. The merge tree is exactly the accepted head 0efaba9412a4b07f49706154cb28942db00d52c9 (88a1e3d0d518e5cae477653c14316609b2b418da); both original histories are retained.

    The investigation separated several operational defects:

    • Progress generation: the native schema projection omits string length bounds. Tiny final narrative quotas could repeatedly fail, and the earlier framed source planner also underallocated some JSON UTF-8 fields. Closed semantic decisions with complete host-rendered labels and exact preplanned per-field byte quotas now cover both framed profiles. Original aggregate/text limits, source/locale/ID checks, immutable snapshots and the single replacement remain enforced. Exhausted generation is nonretryable.
    • Diagnostics/recovery: πŸ›πŸ§‘β€πŸ’» - Bugbot partition exhausts unusable output retries without a diagnostic reasonΒ #920 preserves a finite reason after its existing three unusable completed outputs; πŸ› - Bugbot completes all analysis but fails freshness with opaque provider.unavailable diagnosticsΒ #870 preserves the freshness boundary, safe operation and known provider metadata, with revalidation/reconciliation after retained effects; πŸ› - Branch sync reports a generic workflow failure after detecting merge conflictsΒ #911 reports actionable nonretryable protected-path/over-limit refusals while preserving the policy. Historical provider causes that were not recorded remain unknown.
    • Check reliability: the stdin fixture consumes request EOF, generated artifacts require explicit two-sided conflict handling before verification, reviewed JDK/driver archives use bounded checksum-verified transfer, and all six catalog recovery reads wait for completed canonical reading and effective toolbar availability. Both the early editable-form boundary and the dropped inverse refresh were reproduced without sleeps or business-request retries.

    Accepted-head evidence: CI and Ubuntu/macOS/Windows succeed; matrix attempt1. Linux/macOS: 920 root suites / 18,293 passing tests (35 existing skips). Windows: 919 passing root suites / 18,189 tests, with its existing platform eligibility skips. All three pass 385 extension files / 5,289 tests. Coverage/acceptance budgets and all existing thresholds pass. Native SDK review completed all eight partitions with complete context, every finding state zero and no unresolved review threads. The existing optional probes remain disabled and Approval is advisory neutral; the standard matched-head merge used strict CI protection.

    Official exact-head Codecov comparison: 280/280 hits, zero misses/partials, 100%. Its base tree equals the actual PR base 8db3f6819cca88fa3339bca9ffba5ab30ebbf1e6; an independent intersection with that actual Git diff confirms the same 280 covered lines.

    Actual Domus qualification: consumer a8ff08ea803230760372c1548a54cc360a7c6ce7, SDK pin aeb01425e490744fb0d66ac1184bab1133b0c6ce. Commit: 17 source partitions, 184 admitted requirements, six final batches, 33/120 calls, zero replacements, 28-point summary/remaining quotas. Review: complete 26-partition analysis, zero active findings; the workflow resolved the previous finding. CI: all jobs and both real Docker architectures succeed. The original complete issue body retains SHA256 f5c01613456235e349179026a023ad992b3d95fc427568f27c8f7e31fbf8b2d0. Superseded review-state cancellations remain historical; the latest projection and canonical Review/Verification succeed. This qualification used no manual finding dismissal or thread resolution.

    Relative to that actually executed SDK pin, the accepted SDK changes only the catalog test file: production sources, workflows, dependencies and all four runtime bundles are identical. This explicitly retains native runtime-equivalence evidence; it does not claim Domus executed the later test-only head. Domus PR29 remains independently open.

    #937, #920, #870 and #911 are now completed, with successful lifecycle reconciliation. The other 14 semantic-analysis reports in the 18-issue audit remain open for individual reproduction; this operational correction does not certify those reports as fixed.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

Labels

100%Progress: 100%branchedIndicates that a branch has been created for this issue.bugSomething isn't workingbugfixSomething isn't workingpriority: highCritical issue, needs immediate attention.size: XXLIndicates an extremely large task or issue that requires significant time and effort to complete.

Type

Projects

  • Status
    Done

Milestone

No milestone

Relationships

None yet

Development

No branches or pull requests

Issue actions