Skip to content

Bradbury: an appealed transaction can't be finalized and freezes its contract's finality queue #437

Open

Description

@linoxbt

Network: GenLayer Testnet Bradbury (chain 4221), GenVM v0.3.0-rc10, genlayer-js 2.0.0-rc.3
Consensus contracts: main 0x2E2766cbc3E5e61Ce93bBcdCBb3eAcB82082A019, data 0xc5FA6f82BEe53598825d6edf7E3e24613082c75B
Observed: 2026-11-13, 17:30–19:00 UTC. The transaction was still stuck at the time of writing.
Summary
After a successful appeal, the appealed transaction returned to ACCEPTED. The consensus data contract then reported it ready to
finalize (resolution action 6, Finalize), but finalizeTransaction reverts with 0x0c35bf69 (a selector we could not match to any
error in the ABIs shipped in genlayer-js). finalizeDecisions accepts the call but leaves the transaction ACCEPTED. Transactions to
one contract finalize in order, so every later transaction to that contract also stays ACCEPTED (resolution action 0, NoOp),
long after its own appeal deadline. The contract's finalized state stops advancing, and external messages emitted on finality are
never sent.
Impact
One appeal halts a contract. Every later transaction to it stops finalizing, whoever sent it and whatever it does.
Anyone can trigger it. Appeals are permissionless; our bond was 0.05 GEN. A contract with funds that depend on finality can be
stalled by a stranger for the price of one appeal (if the trigger is reproducible; see Reproducibility).
Downstream effects are real. Our contract (BenchJudge) settles escrows on GenLayer Chain by emitting an arbitrate call on
finality. A case opened after the appeal reached ACCEPTED with a clear verdict, but its verdict never reached the escrow. The
only recovery available to users is a refund after the escrow expires.
No way out at the app level. Redeploying the contract to a fresh address restored finality (2 minutes for a new case), but
state and pending transactions on the old address stay stuck.

Activity

  1. philhenderson05-DEV commented on Nov 13, 2026

    @philhenderson05-DEV

    @linoxbt Have you been able to resolve this issue ?

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

      Milestone

      No milestone

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions