You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
{{ message }}
Repository navigation
Release v1.0.0 and freeze the caller–engine interface #57
Background. The template half of the rollout is done: the code_review question in project-template v0.41.0, and the caller in all 12 repos. The engine half was to freeze the caller–engine interface at v1.0.0, once the quality phase holds on the eval set (precision and recall at or above the baseline, each upgrade kept only where it beats the baseline for its cost). Every v0.x release is published as a GitHub pre-release, which may also be why Dependabot proposes no bumps (#33).
Current state. Latest is v0.3.1 (pre-release, immutable). The interface:
Filed from the 2026-10-31 audit of the NCodeGroup review-bot and project-template design against what was built. This issue stands alone: everything needed to do it is above.
Status: v1.0.0 is released as a full release, not a pre-release. The README's Interface section states the v1 contract (#139, #142). The caller changes the features needed landed before the freeze: closed with a separate outcomes job, and the guard that runs a plain /review only on an open pull request. The quality gate held on the smoke subset: caught 2/3 with the must-not case quiet, now committed as the baseline. Nine consumers were bumped by hand with the caller change. The last acceptance item, Dependabot opening the bump in at least one consumer, is set up in NCodeGroup/PasswordGenerator, which still pins v0.3.1 and has a weekly github-actions run due around 2026-11-07.
Done. v1.0.0 is a full release, not a pre-release, and the README's Interface section is the v1 contract. All 12 callers pin it: this repository, project-template's template and its own copy, and the 10 consumers (PasswordGenerator last, in NCodeGroup/PasswordGenerator#10). I dropped the wait for a live Dependabot bump to finish the rollout now. The README's "Dependabot and pre-releases" section cites the dependabot-core source for why v1 releases are proposed, and project-template's ncode-review group and auto-merge workflow (NCodeGroup/project-template#184) take them from here. The next release is the first one Dependabot will propose.
Activity
polewskm commentedon Nov 1, 2026
Status: v1.0.0 is released as a full release, not a pre-release. The README's Interface section states the v1 contract (#139, #142). The caller changes the features needed landed before the freeze:
closedwith a separateoutcomesjob, and the guard that runs a plain/reviewonly on an open pull request. The quality gate held on the smoke subset: caught 2/3 with the must-not case quiet, now committed as the baseline. Nine consumers were bumped by hand with the caller change. The last acceptance item, Dependabot opening the bump in at least one consumer, is set up in NCodeGroup/PasswordGenerator, which still pins v0.3.1 and has a weekly github-actions run due around 2026-11-07.polewskm commentedon Nov 1, 2026
Done. v1.0.0 is a full release, not a pre-release, and the README's Interface section is the v1 contract. All 12 callers pin it: this repository, project-template's template and its own copy, and the 10 consumers (PasswordGenerator last, in NCodeGroup/PasswordGenerator#10). I dropped the wait for a live Dependabot bump to finish the rollout now. The README's "Dependabot and pre-releases" section cites the dependabot-core source for why v1 releases are proposed, and project-template's
ncode-reviewgroup and auto-merge workflow (NCodeGroup/project-template#184) take them from here. The next release is the first one Dependabot will propose.