Skip to content
Merged
Show file tree
Hide file tree
Changes from all commits
Commits
File filter

Filter by extension

Filter by extension

Conversations
Failed to load comments.
Loading
Jump to
Jump to file
Failed to load files.
Loading
Diff view
Diff view
9 changes: 9 additions & 0 deletions .claude/board/AGENT_LOG.md
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -1,3 +1,12 @@
## 2026-09-07 — plan inventory: 5 read-only Sonnet agents, orchestrator-verified, consolidated to `PLAN-INVENTORY-2026-09-07.md`

- **Why:** operator: *"create an inventory about the plans in `.claude` `.claude/V3` `.claude/plans` — use sonnet agent for grindwork — what is still open what is closed — check if v3 already has the harvest and update — write down any epiphanies and expansion ideas"*, plus *"check the synergies of mississippi queen board game blasgraph shannon EWA known unknowns ternlogq etc"*, plus the per-domain-table / chain-of-masks / SPOG-bakes dialogue.
- **Agents (all `general-purpose` Sonnet, read-only, no cargo, no GitHub writes, each writing ONLY its own tag-file — the orchestrator is the sole writer of every board file):** plans A–K (103 files) · plans L–Z (108 files, 27 special-attention reads in full) · `.claude/v3/` 21 files + harvest cross-check (scope widened mid-run to `.claude/nexgen/` + the 2026-09-01 literature harvest) · W1a/W1b/W1.5 + jc pillars vs code (ndarray `master` `b9afcb9b`) · top-level `.claude/*.md` (71) + STATUS_BOARD/ISSUES/TECH_DEBT/INTEGRATION_PLANS/LATEST_STATE/IDEAS/EPIPHANIES/SUPERSESSION-INDEX census. Tag-files banked verbatim: `exec-runs/plan-inventory-2026-09-07-{plans-a-k,plans-l-z,v3-and-harvest,w-waves-and-jc,toplevel-and-board}.md`.
- **Orchestrator verification (every claim that entered a board file):** confirmed — #1198 merged `3797237b` vs two "In PR" rows; the five W1a symbols at their cited lines; `sigker/src/randomized.rs:49,124` consumes the #7 primitive (the agent had hedged "not wired" — it IS); `types.rs:462` vs `ndarray_bridge.rs:465,493`; Pillar 11 default-deferred at `hambly_lyons.rs:737`; D-CCF-4 rescission at STATUS_BOARD:950; Addendum-15 at INTEGRATION-PLAN:744; `CLAUDE.md:762,765`; lit-harvest D3 wording at `:104`. **Reshaped one:** the "two dangling INTEGRATION_PLANS paths" are cross-repo citations (`:2018` tesseract-rs, `:2339` ndarray), not missing local plans.
- **Synthesis on the main thread (accumulation):** synergy read across `gemm-ternlog-mask-consolidation-v1` §9–§13, `membrane-tiers.md`, `SYNERGY-MAP-S00-S07`, `entropy-closure-causal-ground-v1`, `ew64-witness-unification-v1`, `epistemic-quadrant-materialization-v1`, `mul-ewa-trust-propagation-v1`, `rubicon-loco-rung-cognitive-fabric-v1`, `jc/src/ewa_sandwich.rs`, `spog_tenants.rs`, the four nexgen reader reports, the nexgen plan, and medcare-rs `obo_store.rs`/`domain_block.rs`/`orphanet.rs`/`rails.rs`/`state.rs` for the read-time re-derivation sites.
- **Board writes (this PR):** `PLAN-INVENTORY-2026-09-07.md` (new); TECH_DEBT 7 regrades (W1a ×5 SHIPPED-primitive-side, W1.5 #7 SHIPPED+consumed, TD-SIMD-SWEEP-W2 half-done, #8 ungated note); STATUS_BOARD D-LNC-5a/D-MW-P2 → Shipped; `.claude/v3/` 9 mirrors (README doc-map row + collision note + ruling list; primer §5 ⊘ + §6 row; INTEGRATION-PLAN ⊘; routing.md ⊘; compiled-templates StepMask struck; ENTROPY M2/M24 regrades + M27; COMPONENT-MAP §6 `NestedBands` row; FUTURE-DESIGN 2026-09-07 block; witness-nibble-lane P5); nexgen plan reverse link; EPIPHANIES ×4; IDEAS ×5; LATEST_STATE delta. Gates: `append_only_gate.py origin/main`, `citation_decay.py --since`, supersession index regenerated LAST.
- **Not done, on purpose:** no code, no plan-header edits in other owners' plans (recorded in §1a instead), no adjudication of the W2a contradiction, no force-push anywhere (the designated branch's remote tip was already-merged history, so the push is a fast-forward).

## 2026-09-06 — temporal audit arc: 12 read-only agents + 2 probes, orchestrator-gated (#1198)

- **Why:** operator asked for an archaeology + migration audit of the alpha channel, the rung ladder and the octopus/SPOG addressing, then for the delta-backed alpha layer, then for the findings to be written down as a durable reference.
Expand Down
62 changes: 61 additions & 1 deletion .claude/board/EPIPHANIES.md
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -1,6 +1,66 @@
## 2026-09-07 — E-A-PLAN-INVENTORY-FINDS-THE-BOARD-LAGS-THE-TREE-IN-BOTH-DIRECTIONS-1 — status cells decay at the rate of the tree, not of the file

**Status:** FINDING, measured (five read-only Sonnet agents; every claim below re-verified by the orchestrator at a tree line, not a tag-file line). Full census: `.claude/board/PLAN-INVENTORY-2026-09-07.md`; evidence: `exec-runs/plan-inventory-2026-09-07-*.md`.
**Confidence:** High for every `file:line` row; the D-id coverage percentage is measured on the A–K half of `.claude/plans/` only.

**The numbers.** 211 plans: 149 OPEN, 13 CLOSED, 9 SUPERSEDED, 40 AMBIGUOUS (35 with no status line at all — 22 of them the batch-landed `3DGS-*` design genre). V3 waves: W0 closed; W1 mechanism closed, adoption partial; W2 partial and self-contradictory; W3/W4 partial; W5/W6 open, W6's premise rescinded. W1a SIMD: 4/5 shipped, GATHER partial (API on every backend, x86 body a scalar polyfill). W1b: 0/5 TD entries closed, 1/7 files migrated (179 raw-intrinsic lines across five crates). W1.5: #6, #7 shipped and consumed, #8 unbuilt but ungated.

**Direction one — docs still say Open for work on `main`.** Five `TECH_DEBT` rows said `Open` for primitives that have been on ndarray `master` for months (`simd_scalar.rs:1684,1709,1799,1887,1916`); W1.5 #7 said `Deferred` while `ndarray/src/hpc/randomized_signature.rs:292` ships it and `sigker/src/randomized.rs:124` consumes it — a THREE-way inconsistency, two knowledge docs having said SHIPPED since 2026-09-02; `STATUS_BOARD` D-LNC-5a/D-MW-P2 read `In PR #1198` with #1198 merged (`3797237b`); ENTROPY M2 said `QUEUED` nine weeks after D-PERT-1 shipped; `compiled-templates.md` said `StepMask` does not exist eight weeks after it did; `self-reasoning-substrate-v1.md:15` says "doc-only, no code" over four D-SRS rows that read Shipped with 147 tests between them. All but the last two are regraded in this PR (append-only strike-through with the tree line).

**Direction two — docs still carry a rescinded premise or an unminted id.** `D-CCF-4` (the `0x1000` retirement) was RESCINDED on 2026-07-03 and sat on `STATUS_BOARD:950` for nine weeks while `INTEGRATION-PLAN.md:110`, `routing.md:104-106` and the primer §5 kept describing the marker as temporary with a 100 %-adoption trigger — no V3 file carried the rescission. W2a is stated two incompatible ways in ONE file (Addendum-12a: a new gated `BoardAggregates` tenant; Addendum-15: "SHIPPED as `ValueTenant::Kanban`", the per-ROW tenant its own sibling doc calls a sibling, not a substitute). `D-GRAPH-1`, `D-TRUTH-1`, `D-INFER-DEDUCTIONS-RELATION-BLIND` are cited by two plans and exist on no board row.

**The gap the board already names, re-measured.** `ISS-PLAN-TRACKING-IS-UNENFORCED`: on the A–K half, **314 of 559 D-id citations (56 %) have no `STATUS_BOARD` row; 26 plans have zero coverage**. Two instrument traps, both caught: the regex `D-[A-Z]+(-[A-Z0-9]+)+` matches the tail of `E-READ-NOT-GREP` as `D-NOT-GREP` (81 false positives across 43 files); and the house style `D-<FULL-SENTENCE>-N` is a *finding* citation, not a deliverable — "no board row" is evidence only after the id's grammar is checked. `INTEGRATION_PLANS.md` names 58 of 211 plan files nowhere.

**The harvest was invisible from V3.** `.claude/v3/` referenced neither `.claude/nexgen/` nor the 2026-09-01 literature harvest; its every "nexgen" meant `openproject-nexgen-rs`. Nine mirrors landed (README row, primer §5/§6, INTEGRATION-PLAN, routing, compiled-templates, ENTROPY M27, COMPONENT-MAP §6, FUTURE-DESIGN, witness-lane P5) and the nexgen plan links back.

**Verification reshaped one finding — which is why the agents' files are evidence, not verdicts.** The top-level agent reported "two cited plan paths that do not exist"; both are cross-repo citations (`INTEGRATION_PLANS.md:2018` → tesseract-rs, `:2339` → ndarray) misread as local. The agent that hedged "#7 not yet wired into sigker" was wrong in the OTHER direction — it is wired. The rule this leaves: **a status cell is a claim about the tree, so a regrade cites the tree (`file:line` on the branch), never the report that noticed it.**

## 2026-09-07 — E-EVERY-DOMAIN-IS-A-TABLE-AND-A-CROSSWALK-IS-A-CHAIN-OF-MASKS-1 (OPERATOR-RULED) — no DataFusion joins, ever; the six blockers were read-time re-derivation

**Status:** RULING (operator, 2026-09-07, verbatim below) + FINDING for the mechanism mapping (every site `file:line`) + CONJECTURE for the throughput claim until PROBE-CROSSWALK-MASK-1 runs (IDEAS 2026-09-07).
**Confidence:** High on the sites and on the bounds (all measured in `gemm-ternlog-mask-consolidation-v1` §12–§13 and D-GTM-0n/P3); medium on the unification until one probe joins two legs.

**The ruling.** *"i mean every domain is just another table keyed by CUI STDID (snomed) loinc etc — its a chain effect with masking, no datafusion joins ever."*

**What it dissolves.** Every open blocker in the SPOG / alpha / medcare / DataFusion arc is the same shape: **something decided once upstream is re-derived at read time, per row.** The ontology category is stamped into `value[96]` and read back per row (`medcare-cohorts/src/obo_store.rs:16-18,77,681`); `Domain::of_row` classifies per row (`orphanet.rs:165`, `rails.rs:432`); `FacetRegime::PerRowTui` resolves the regime per row (`domain_block.rs:259,695`, `quad_tenant.rs:169,215`); `graph_of(addr)` is right in direction (G read from the key, `contract/src/spog_tenants.rs:38`) but resolved per claim by a linear scan over tenants (`:87`); V1 external-id identity re-derives the row from an id the key already is; and Lance row identity is re-materialised by the scanner (`medcare-server/src/state.rs:900,936` `with_row_id = true`, `with_row_addr = true`). One table per G removes the first four reads (the domain IS the table); V3 lane-local addresses remove the fifth; containment removes the sixth.

**The mechanism, named at T1.** The quad's 4×24 slots are four pre-resolved foreign keys — slot 0 the own key; CUI present in 8/8 domains as the hub; FMA the anatomy↔imaging bridge; ICD↔MONDO inside disease. A crosswalk is a chain: `eq_u32_to_mask` over table n's FK column (`ndarray/src/simd_int_ops.rs:562`), `mask_ternlog` with the incoming survivors (`:983`; `AND3` / `AND_ANDNOT2` by name, `membrane-tiers.md` T1), and the survivors' key set is the needle set of table n+1. **Nothing is joined: the mask-out of hop n IS the mask-in of hop n+1.** The one forbidden move is a mask-AND across two tables — that is a join in disguise, and it is exactly what the nexgen plan's room 18 already rejects at the seal ("a derived read that has to AND masks from two semantic families is a violation"). This is the schema-level form of the mask plan's own invariant (§11: *substrate == mask geometry == projection surface*).

**The bounds that ride with the claim (none may be dropped when it is cited).** D-GTM-0j: masks win on Boolean relations at EVERY density (297× vs dense f32) — the boundary is TYPE, not density; a hop that must accumulate a value (evidence strength, NARS frequency) is not a mask hop and goes to the valued arm (blasgraph semirings over CSR; D-GTM-0g, the CSR SpMV arm, is unrun). D-GTM-0k: 0 bytes/step, by a counting allocator. D-GTM-0n/P3: chaining pays (`T3/T1` → 0.50 by K=8) only while the masks stay L2-resident (ratio back to 1.03 at a 512 KiB mask) and only above ~0.1 % active — a crosswalk hop that thins the survivors below that must switch to sparse. D-GTM-0l: packed-prefix routing does NOT carry long-range relations (1.08× at k=3 on physical addresses) — cross-domain hops ride the FK columns, never prefix locality between tables. `E-Q8`: six-neighbourness does no work — no neighbourhood structure between domains is assumed.

**The unblock order (the dialogue's, confirmed against the tree).** (1) one table per domain — SPOG-aware bakes, one artifact per G; (2) V3 lane-local addresses (the mint side already bangs on V1: `E-A-V3-MINT-MUST-NEVER-DEGRADE-TO-V1-1`); (3) `ogar-r2il` gets its first consumer via `lance-graph-ogar` — today it has none (only `OGAR/Cargo.toml` names it); (4) DataFusion containment — both scanner flags off, pinned by a test, no new surface (`E-PLANNING-MIGRATES-TO-LOCO-R2IL-DATAFUSION-IS-GRACE-PERIOD-1`). Order matters: (4) before (1) leaves the consumer with no identity but the flags.

**Falsifier.** PROBE-CROSSWALK-MASK-1: survivor SETS identical to the DataFusion path on one fixture; if they differ, the FK reading of the slots is wrong before the algebra is.

## 2026-09-07 — E-SEVEN-HARVEST-SOURCES-ONE-OBJECT-THE-VERSION-KEYED-MASK-SET-1 — Mississippi Queen, Shannon, EWA, known unknowns, ternlogq and blasgraph are readings of `NestedBands`

**Status:** SYNTHESIS [H] — each leg cites a measured or ruled source; the unification is unmeasured until a probe joins two legs (the first candidate: PROBE-CROSSWALK-MASK-1 + the `SettlementCell` classifier, IDEAS 2026-09-07).
**Confidence:** Medium. The legs are [G]/[H] individually; "one object" is the claim under test.

- **Mississippi Queen** (`ndarray/.claude/plans/gemm-ternlog-mask-consolidation-v1.md` §9–§11): reveal-ahead-of-cursor (M1), tile-serves-every-boat with cache key `(mask generation, panel index)` (M1b), the ±1 lookahead ladder (M2), the coal budget for re-chaining (M3). The nexgen plan's room 10 says time travel is free because every `NestedBands` is version-keyed and never rewritten. **These are one cache: the mask generation IS the Lance version**, and the coal budget IS the rollover budget (D-NXG-5). Do not build a second invalidation scheme. The hexagon was regraded [S]→[H] and `E-Q8` shows degree-1 matches hex to four decimals at 5.5× less memory — what survives of the board is the reveal and the budget, not the tiling.
- **Shannon** (`entropy-closure-causal-ground-v1` §4; nexgen E-NXG-19): entropy measures WHERE closure is, never WHAT kind of hole (CE64 59–60) nor HOW it may be asserted (61–63); measured, entropy LAGS the popcount budget by five steps on a real shift and is the did-the-split-help read (0.834 → 0.912), not the timer. The literature harvest's greedy INFO_GAIN Ω(n/log n) bound adds: hop order by expected survivor reduction is near-optimal — a sort over popcounts, no planner.
- **EWA** (`jc/src/ewa_sandwich.rs`; `mul-ewa-trust-propagation-v1` §0a/§0b; lit-harvest #27 — three operations share the word): the sandwich is certified NUMERICALLY only (PSD ≥ 0.999, tightness 1.467×); "geometry decides WHERE, never WHAT" (F-MEP-0a) and the closed-graph monotonicity STOP (F-MEP-0d) are the fences. On a crosswalk hop the discrete Σ trace already exists: `popcount(survivors)`. EWA may rank which hop to explore; it may not elevate a survivor to a fact.
- **Known unknowns** (`entropy-closure` SettlementCells; `epistemic-quadrant-materialization-v1` §4c–§4e; `mul-ewa` "the pothole is a TYPED ABSENCE"): a known unknown is a hop whose survivor mask has popcount > 1 — alternatives = the mask, discriminators = the FK columns not yet swept, evidence needed = the sweep. Crystal / Glass / GroundedUnresolved / Fog read off `(popcount, discriminator present, FK grounded)`; ADMIT = the column exists, BUDGET = popcount, PERMIT = `ReasoningBand`, TEST = the sweep. The fork-return rule holds unchanged: only the elimination (the mask) comes back.
- **ternlogq** (`membrane-tiers.md`; OGAR #298; nexgen rooms 4/18/20): `TERNLOG 0x86` is the only surviving loco call and its value byte is the program; the eight named immediates are a complete mask ISA; room 18's family-separation rule is the mechanical "no joins". A crosswalk program = `RANK` + `TERNLOG` per hop.
- **blasgraph** (`SYNERGY-MAP-S00-S07` §8.0; D-GTM-0j): integer-only HDR semiring algebra, no splat; the boundary with masks is TYPE — Boolean relations are masks, valued relations are semirings over CSR (D-GTM-0g unrun decides where). K0..K7, the SPO 2³ triadic projections, are the eight Boolean masks of one quad row.

**One object.** The shipped struct is version-keyed over one column with no classid: `pub struct NestedBands` at `crates/lance-graph-planner/src/nested_bands.rs:91-105`. A sealed NestedBands + overlap matrix per (classid, version) is the nexgen plan's PROPOSED room-26 shape, not the shipped D-NXG-1 key (Codex review on #1218 caught this entry's first draft implying the key was shipped) — read by each source its own way — search, monitoring, rank, basin, drift, quorum, hop order, known-unknown census (nexgen room 26 said as much before the crosswalk reading existed). **The fence that keeps it one object and not a god-field:** rung, band, plasticity and "style as a byte string of immediates" are four different things (next entry).
Comment thread
coderabbitai[bot] marked this conversation as resolved.

## 2026-09-07 — E-RUNG-BAND-AND-PLASTICITY-ARE-THREE-AXES-NEVER-ONE-LEVEL-FIELD-1 — level of processing, level of assertion, and how content changes do not share a byte

**Status:** FENCE (operator caution 2026-09-07 — "rung 0–9 and bits 61..63 must never be folded into one level field" — on top of two prior rulings).
**Confidence:** High — three shipped carriers with three cardinalities.

- **Rung 0–9 = level of PROCESSING**, a temporal horizon: the `RungLevel` discriminant (`cognitive_shader.rs:157`), consumed by `EpistemicMode::for_rung` (`planner/src/temporal.rs:87-97`: 0..=4 Strict, 5..=8 Aware, 9 Retro) — it decides which versions a reader may see. Ten values.
- **`ReasoningBand` bits 61..63 = level of ASSERTION**, Tarski permission (`entropy-closure-causal-ground-v1` §4; `causal-edge::layout`) — it decides what a settled closure may be asserted as. Eight values. `ISS-RUNG-VS-BAND-CARDINALITY-COLLISION` (2026-08-26) already records that the two share endpoint names with different cardinalities, and `ISS-REASONING-BAND-GATES-NOTHING` that the band gates no control loop yet — the temptation to "just use rung" is live.
- **`PlasticityState` 3-bit S/P/O = how content CHANGES** (`causal-edge/src/plasticity.rs`); `epistemic-quadrant-materialization-v1` §4b refused "STDP = rung 3" for exactly this reason — *a rung says what content IS, a plasticity mode says how it CHANGES; different axes* — and the substrate already agrees (per-plane hot/frozen is axis-local).
- The nexgen "thinking style = a byte string of immediates" (room 4) is a **fourth** thing, a program, not a level.

**Consequence for the chain-of-masks reading:** PERMIT is the band; the readable horizon is the rung; the mask is neither. **Falsifier / gate:** any struct, enum or lane that stores two of the three in one field, or any `level: u8` that is read as more than one of them, is a LAYOUT-BREAK-class defect (`v3-envelope-auditor` verdict); a `/v3-audit` grep for such fields is the cheap pre-commit check (not yet added — recorded so the next session adds it rather than re-deriving the fence).

## 2026-09-07 — E-PLUG-AND-PLAY-IS-THE-DECLARATION-NOT-A-TABLE-1 — my fix rebuilt the lockstep it was closing

**Status:** FINDING, measured. Fixed in this PR (7 tests, both guards disable-verified).
**Status:** FINDING, measured. Fixed in the PR that landed this entry, #1216 (7 tests, both guards disable-verified).
**Confidence:** High — the failure mode is demonstrated by a test that goes red when the scoping is restored.

**Operator ruling (2026-09-07):** *"plug and play already has all the domains,
Expand Down
Loading
Loading